I'm developing a game, that's probably obvious by now. It's going to a fusion of the three games in the title of this thread.

Essentially right now, I want some feedback on this screenshot.



Those are two screenshots from the same game engine, but both are representing the players dorm in a different graphical style.

One, is the sketched out dorm:



and the other is a pixelated/normal graphics room:

(Note the green borders are collision boxes that will be invisible in the final game)



Which is better looking? Note these are placeholders, they don't represent the final versions, but they do represent the styles.

I don't know if that's sarcasm, or you're being serious. lol.

Just to clarify, the final one won't look that bad.

I'm being completely serious

In reply to both of these, it will be click and drag to move around.

Also, the reason I'm going with sketched areas is that there will be 8 areas that are reused throughout the game. Seeing as the game will take place in one in-game year in the same town. The dungeons will have parts, but they will be generated if things go as planned.

The collision itself will be overlayed with collision maps I'll be building in Tiled. Some will be isometric, and other ortho. depending on the map.

For looks, i'd clearly say the sketched one.
When i compare the screenshots, i look at the tile-based and think "why? another one of those." but when i look at the sketched one i think "This seems interesting, wanna see more."

But for control, i'd say that the tile-based might be easiest for the player to understand and interact with, when using click and drag, while the sketched one would be better of with a different control system such as point and click.

My conclusion would be, pick the sketched one, it have the best "feel".

Totally agree about the sketched interface - even your rough version looks more appealing.  It's even making me reconsider some things I was planning to do with standard tiles.

Looking good man.

Totally the sketched look.  No question whatsoever.

Basically, it's 8-bit characters because drawing each frame for the character would simply be too hard and time consuming for the type of game this is going to be. Plus. the 8-bit will complement the sketched environments, which will look pretty cool.

There's a screen with the player put in.
I'll probably have to implement a sprite shadow system or just draw them on myself. Not so sure on which yet.

I think I liked the 1st sketch better, I don't know if it was the view point, or the fact that you only needed to see the north wall, or maybe it's the thin border around the walls.  Also, if there's a rug in the room, you know there's a key under it    

There's some obvious errors, but what do you think of this environment?

Thank you!

Do you see anything you'd think I should change? I've already decided to remove the sidewalk so the player has more walking space.

I agree, blacking out the lines after scanning makes them look too uniform and mechanical. I'd suggest getting yourself a nice brush pen to do the thick lines with, and maybe inking some of the finer detail with a fineliner.

The sketchiness works, but I would suggest watching out when it comes to perspectives.

In what you've posted there are several of instances where the lines formed aren't parallel where they should be (Such as the door in the 'from the corner view'.) The main reason bring this up is that when you have lines that people know should be parallel can cause a sense of disquiet, which may or may not be what you intended to do.

If all of the art is off to the same degree, it doesn't make too much of a difference, because it will be come 'normal' at least in the sense of what you're playing with. But, if your later art ends up being better about perspective/square/parallel, but you leave your earlier attempts in, people (Especially those like me, heh) will spend a lot of time wondering why the room is so 'off'.

This can, of course, be used as a form of foreshadowing in your game, or an indication of things going wrong. Say, if most of the world is four-square, then you get one room where the windows aren't quite square, or the doors are lopsided. That room will be even more off-putting or creepy. Or, if your game has things 'getting worse' in some way, several images of the same rooms gradually changing can affect the mood.