All of us should respect others point of view even if it is completely different than our.
Do not be intimidated judges, I appreciate your work.
And remeber this is only fun:).
In my opinion there will be no perfect solution for judging.
The idea of judging and community voting with giving feedback is realy good.
We can describe the problem in this way: how to avoid wrong positioning in case if of the rate is completely different than other.
Maybe we should try e.g. expected value rather than arithmetic mean of all scores
But there still will be only smoothing:)