Community Voting

[appel]

Strip Poker 4K 

[Markus_Persson]

That would be both disturbing and awesome at the same time!

[Alan_W]

Strip Poker 4K 

Yeah, but think of all the webcam shots of defeated players.  Doesn't bare thinking about 

Games published by our own members! Go get 'em!

[SimonH]

Ok, I've done my voting but I feel unsatisfied...
I've played all the games and I'd have liked to have have given each one a 1-5 rating, but I only had 25 stars to give - I'm lazy so I just gave 5 each to my favourite 5 games. It's a shame really, I'd have liked to have shown some appreciation to every entrant, even if it was only 1 star, that still feels better than nothing.
I think the final results will tend to favour the high-end games for this reason - it's too much like hard work to share out the marks!
Would it be possible to allow a 1-5 rating for every game next year?

[davidc]

I feel the same, a 1-5 rating for each might allow my vote to reflect more how I feel. As it stands, I didn't award any 5 pointers to anyone as it just used up too many points. I could barely even spare a point for my own game 

Also, is there a reason we can't change the vote after entering it? It takes a while to go through all the games, so I ended up keeping a spreadsheet of all the scores then entering them in when done. This took a couple of evenings, and there were still a couple of games that i didn't really spend much time on as they just didn't grab me straight away.

[pjt33]

It takes a while to go through all the games, so I ended up keeping a spreadsheet of all the scores then entering them in when done. This took a couple of evenings, and there were still a couple of games that i didn't really spend much time on as they just didn't grab me straight away.

I spent four lunchtimes going through the games and storing notes and approximate scores. Then I went back through my notes, listed the games in order, and worked on cut-off points which I felt reflected my opinions fairly and didn't go over 25. If it didn't grab me within a couple of minutes then it didn't get points because a minigame should be something you can enjoy immediately.

I think I'll follow Dzzd in posting my allocation. Note that I deliberately chose not to vote for my own game, because I don't feel right doing that.

4 points
Kuest - 4K
Burning Man
GTA4K

All three are good fun and have some replayability. I don't think I can pick an overall winner between them.

3 points
4 Freedom -- technically impressive, but jolly hard (and I think mainly because of the control scheme)
TrickShot -- good fun, just needs a quick reset so I get to be doing something for more than 10% of the time I spend playing

2 points
Driver4K -- fun, controls a bit irritating

1 point
Falcon4k -- technically good but the perspective makes it very hard to play
Cap4Hold -- interesting idea. Crashed with AIOOBE
Don't Reach The Square -- nice effects, not much depth
Little Worlds4k -- not much depth, but interesting enough that I played until I finished it
Greedy Snakes 4k -- nice twist

[delt0r]

Just tried 4 different games and non of them worked with the same class not found exception. What ever happed to providing a normal jar rather than a pack200 as per the applet sun standards.

[steveyO]

Just tried 4 different games and non of them worked with the same class not found exception. What ever happed to providing a normal jar rather than a pack200 as per the applet sun standards.

Its a shame really, doesnt do much for the overall perception of Java Applets. For me the games have all failed due to ClassNotFound on 3 seperate PC's  (all with JRE1.5, but without JDK's, coincidence?). 

Just realized, it was you that started the below thread, but I guess its still relevant as the issue is not yet resolved..
http://www.java-gaming.org/topics/many-4k-applets-not-working/21771/view.html

[DzzD]

To make the user experience better... perhaps java4k should only send the JAR and not the pack.gz version no matter what the client says...

The pack.gz is there to qualify as meeting the 4k limit... only the judges care, the general user does not really care...

I can see the point of not following this advice right now    using PACK2000 to show to the public on J4K is just adding incompatibilities where there is already too much... what the benefit ? sure you wont pay more for the 3 bytes overflow on network bandwith

[dishmoth]

So many games, so few points!

Here's where my points went.

5 points
Burning Man - Unusual, original, and has some great levels.  I'd be interested to see this as a full (>4k) game.

4 points
Virus - A surprisingly relaxing war game.
VVVV - Unbelievably sadistic.  I worry for the sanity of anyone who tries to complete it.

3 points
GTA - I like running over pedestrians.  Does that make me a bad person?
Bug War - Overcomplicated but engrossing.

2 points
BoxBot - Maybe not technically impressive, but it felt like a complete game.
Falcon - Felt more solid than a lot of Zaxxon clones I've played in the past.

1 point
Greedy Snakes - Simple but pleasant.  The enemy snake is a surprisingly good competitor.
Assassins - Hardly any gameplay, but I really, really liked the graphics.

Games published by our own members! Go get 'em!

[CaptainJester]

So many games, so few points!

Here's where my points went.

5 points
Burning Man - Unusual, original, and has some great levels.  I'd be interested to see this as a full (>4k) game.

4 points
Virus - A surprisingly relaxing war game.
VVVV - Unbelievably sadistic.  I worry for the sanity of anyone who tries to complete it.

3 points
GTA - I like running over pedestrians.  Does that make me a bad person?
Bug War - Overcomplicated but engrossing.

2 points
BoxBot - Maybe not technically impressive, but it felt like a complete game.
Falcon - Felt more solid than a lot of Zaxxon clones I've played in the past.

1 point
Greedy Snakes - Simple but pleasant.  The enemy snake is a surprisingly good competitor.
Assassins - Hardly any gameplay, but I really, really liked the graphics.

That's only 15 points.  You have 25.

[Riven]

That's only 15 points.  You have 25.

Epic FAIL

1*5 + 2*4 + 2*3 + 2*2 + 2*1 = 25

[dishmoth]

That's only 15 points.  You have 25.

I kept 10 points for myself to cover admin costs.

[CaptainJester]

Epic FAIL

1*5 + 2*4 + 2*3 + 2*2 + 2*1 = 25

LOL, oops.

[appel]

I kept 10 points for myself to cover admin costs.

You cannot vote unless you use up all your 25 points.

[appel]

Only two more days left of community voting!!!

Get your vote in today or by midnight tomorrow!

[appel]

Ok, all done. Voting results will be published tomorrow night.

Thanks all!